Il test dell'ortoressia nervosa

Scritto il
Pubblicato indr greger , dr gregor , dr michael greger , eating disorders , how not to die , michael greger , nervosa , nutrition facts , nutritionfacts.org , orthorexia , orthorexia nervosa , orthorexia quiz , orthorexia recovery , orthorexia symptoms , orthorexia test , orthorexia treatment , the

Guarda come ottieni il tuo punteggio nel test “diagnostico” di ortoressia.

I nuovi iscritti alla nostra e-newsletter ricevono sempre un omaggio. Prendi il tuo qui:
https://nutritionfacts.org/subscribe/

Era una pazzia o cosa?! Questo è l'ultimo di una serie di tre video. Nel caso in cui ti sei perso i primi due, sono l'ortoressia un vero disturbo alimentare? (http://nutritionfacts.org/video/is-orthorexia-a-real-eating-disorder) e sintomi di ortoressia nervosa (http://nutritionfacts.org/video/orthorexia-nervosa-symptoms). <br/>
Mentre, come penso che vedrai chiaramente dopo aver visto l'intera serie in tre parti, l'ortoressia non può essere considerata un legittimo disturbo alimentare, ci sono molto reali e molto gravi disturbi alimentari (come anoressia e bulimia) che non dovrebbero essere presi alla leggera. Se tu o una persona cara soffrite di una di queste diagnosi, cercate immediatamente l'aiuto di un professionista.

Hai una domanda su questo video? Lascialo nella sezione commenti su http://nutritionfacts.org/video/the-orthorexia-nervosa-test e qualcuno su il team di NutritionFacts.org cercherà di rispondere.

Vuoi avere un elenco di link a tutte le fonti scientifiche utilizzate in questo video? Fare clic su Fonti citate su http://nutritionfacts.org/video/the-orthorexia-nervosa-test. Troverai anche una trascrizione e ringraziamenti per il video, il mio blog e il programma del tour di conferenze, e un modo semplice per cercare (anche nella lingua tradotta) attraverso i nostri video che coprono più di 2,000 argomenti di salute.

Se preferisci guardare questi video su YouTube, iscriviti al mio canale YouTube qui:

100 Risposte a “Il test dell'ortoressia nervosa”

  1. love how everyone here (including dr greger) defers to science & peer-reviewed publications when it supports their worldview but then denigrates that same institution when it doesn't. double standard & confirmation bias much? check out all the horror stories of ex-vegans on youtube. orthorexia is seriously real: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SSDJoKLWSkw

  4. I appreciate how stupid the orthorexia survey questions are, but what Dr. Greger simply called "bad PMS" in passing is a legitimate and serious mental health problem. PMDD can involve feeling severely depressed and even suicidal, and for certain people, the condition is so unmanageable that they have no choice but to have a hysterectomy. I usually respect and take seriously the content on this channel, but making off-hand comments that lump something like PMDD into the same category as "fake" mental health disorders is extremely irresponsible. I think we should all also keep in mind that Dr. Greger, while clearly an excellent doctor when it comes to topics related to nutrition, is not a psychologist or psychiatrist, nor is there a licensed mental health care professional on the Nutrition Facts team.

  5. What if the animal product industries came up with the concept and test to try to put people in institutions to protect their profits? Sounds like a conspiracy theory, I know, but I wouldn't put it past them, especially because they know their days are numbered. What else are psychopath, murderous billionaires to do?

  6. Bahahahaha! Sorry…I had organic beer for breakfast…my day off..3..600 calories.

    Next is brunch…maybe another 600 calories..and a nap after some switch hit bunny rope action with my husband. Vegans are not boring sexless, nutrition obsessed assholes. 🙂

    I have problem with fun. Funarexia.

    PS..I am crazy & delusional

  10. I can imagine a case where someone could get completely obsessed with BAD nutritional myths like “cleansing” or “detox” that could make them really really sick. Or people following a carnivore diet where they get convinced that eating any plants will kill them. I’d call that an eating disorder that doesn’t fall under a different category. I’d think that sort of stuff would be “orthorexia”.

  11. Lol, I guess I'm "orthorexic." This sounds like something the big food companies created to make people question their healthy lifestyle. Not unlike the commercials in which they list the chemical composition of Brussels sprouts to demonstrate that all foods are comprised of chemicals. They conclude the commercial by implying, since all foods are comprised of chemicals, their heavily processed foods can also be considered healthy. As far as I'm concerned, both attempts are an epic fail.

  17. That questionnare is a joke " do you think supermarkets sell unhealthy food" duh yes they do! Thats not mental illness thats just people wanting to diagnose people who are healthy! Its most ridiculous thing ive heard

  19. Well they had to do something. Think of all the money they are loosing on pharmaceuticals and unnecessary surgeries because of healthy eaters.

  20. I personally have had orthorexia however these questionnaires are not accurate…. obviously screwed grossly as well. Orthorexia is about obsessive behavior, thoughts, tied with your personal value to how you eat. For instance if you don't eat everything organic, raw, and you cant feel calm during your meal, you'll have anxiety, feel horrible about yourself as a person, and feel not good enough and a failure… or that your dirty and not "high vibe"… just an example of what actual orthorexia is. It's a fine line huge grey area space that people that don't have OCD or anxiety or aren't prone to those things or depression would never experience or understand. Its experienceing high anxiety about weather or not the things you eat are the healthiest and can grow into fear of being in public spaces, eating at restaurants, etc. Its a thing. 💖

  22. Never heard of this "ailment" before … thanks for the video. Never heard of this journal before either, but the publisher is credible.
    The war promoting good public health is fought on many fronts.

  28. “At present, are you alone when having meals?” Wtf? What if you have no one who will eat with you—how is that my fault? Or what if gasp you live alone like Dr. Greger said? This question needs to be rephrased to specifically address people who intentionally choose to eat alone because of health concerns—not out of dislike for other people. Wow, these questions are highly flawed.

  30. I laughed out loud the entire video! Thanks Dr Greger! You’re awesome. I’m a sick sick puppy! 😂. What will food industry and big pharm come up with next!? Nice try, but you’re not affecting this gal. Carry on…. as far as I’m concerned, if their mouths are open, they’re lying 🤥

  34. I have 33! I'm single and l know that what you eat makes how you look and that shops sell unhealthy food 🙂 wow I have ortorexia!

  36. I watched my parents going from store to store in order to get the cheapest whatever… They both died of cancer, were always fighting obesity, etc. I decided that I was going to eat as healthy as possible, including organic, and not worry so much about the cost. I'm glad I'm not contributing to the poisoning of my body. I buy healthy ingredients. Make tasty food, and eat 3 or more times a day. Sounds pretty 'normal' to me.

  38. the test should have more questions about peoples worries and obsession about only eating healthy – causing negativities in their life.. this test just seems to be about peoples awareness and analytical desires.

  39. Yes, the thought of food worries me daily, before I hit the gym. I don't want to puke or get cramps. It's common sense. Not orthorexic.

  51. I got under 30, I have a healthy obsession with eating healthy, often I worry too much but I don't think I'm sick. I ate a whole bag of potato chips last night at the movies, it is the worst thing in my diet but I like eating whole foods, that doesn't make me crazy does it? I worry about calories in every single thing I eat, but I'm the opposite of most, I worry about trying to eat the most calories as possible because I struggle to eat enough every day so I love calories

  54. I am sure that they are currently working on a prescription drug to combat the scourge of Orthorexia Nervosa . Until then, your doctor will prescribe cheese burgers and milkshakes.

  59. I think the definition should be amended to people who obsess about over unfounded claims about healthy foods. Like claiming that raw foods are always better, or that they have to constantly detox with juice fasts…

  62. Humans recognizing danger and seeking to avoid it for survival is not a new thing. In today's world our hand-to-mouth, self-reliant way of living is gone and leaves a whole set of new and complicated dangers to avoid. So… some of us are evolving to adapt for survival and longevity. Sorry not sorry.

    Poisons and a zillion other contaminants are all around us. Yes, this sucks and causes anxiety in those who recognize it. :-/ I think we need to reshape our world, not rationalize the insanity that is the food industry today.

    This orthorexia thing is absurd.

  65. People shouldn't be drugged for haveing otherxia. Otherxia doesnt make much sense and is kinda rediculous and crazy to care if people wana be super healthy. If people wana eat healthy and care about health more than 99percent of the population then let them.

    Its better to worry about the quality of your food than if your eating choices were conditioned worries about your health.
    Everyone is mentally ill according to dsm5.
    It seems like this test wants to label people with a mental disorder if they dont fit the norm that is generally unhealthy or if they dont wana eat an unhealthy diet and if they rather be healthier than everyone else or try to choose about the healthiest options, but
    Im not saying people should be so obsessed about being healthy that the individual thinks it causes problems in their own life. Spending over an hour grocery shopping weekly and counting calories and nutrition and getting a nutrtion blood test can be helpful for individuals to eat healthier, especially at first until they figure out what they should eat, but im not saying people need to continue doing that afterwards or even do it at all.

    This test is dumb and bad.

    Plenty of people pay more for healthy food and that's a good thing.

    I dont eat super healthy and i dont try to, i usually eat cookies or chips or icecream or chocolate or earth balence buttery spread, or oil, about daily and sometimes veganaise and mock meat.
    So im probably not othorexic, but for those who r labeled as such i dont think its nessicarily wrong for them to want to eat healthy.

    it is bad for someone to eat an unhealthy diet while thinking it is healthy, such as being anorexic but thinking its healthy and adequate.

    Mental disorders r opinions, why give a group of corrupt psychiatrists the power to label like everyone with a disorder then have the gov use that excuse to lock people up and forcefully drug them simply for having what they claim is a mental disorder, even they can do this to people who dont even fit the criteria of a mental disorder and just lie or vaguely interpret the definition so much that everyone would fit it. The mental health industry is rich and they act like the thought police.
    Whats the point of having a constitution when they can come lock u up and drug u for doing almost anything, without even having any proof that u did an action they deem as bad, simple lies are enough for some of them to lock people up and drug them for years maybe for life, and its disgusting, even locking up and drugging kids agianst their will for things like being hyper.
    The mental health industry should not be allowed to force or coerce people to do anything cuz they say they have a mental disorder.

    Drugs r not the answer. People have free will. Drugs cant force someone to be happy. Being happy is a choice. Drugs r not alive, they have no soul or spirt, they cant possess someone and control them like robots, yet many mental health liars act like they do.

    People should be allowed to do what they want as long as they didnt and do not murder, abuse, kidnap, wrongfully touch, threaten w a weapon or endanger wrongfuly, or wrongfuly steal, damage, touch or endanger others property, and kno the risks and benifits of what they wana do and kno how to properly do what they wana do and kno what they r doing.
    And if they did any of those bad things and r deemed rehabed and safe enough to be in public and free then they should also be allowed to do what they want as long as it doesn't include those bad things and they kno the risks and benifits of what they wana do, and kno how to properly do what they wana do and kno what they r doing.

  67. It is irresponsible in my opinion to mock a disorder which your followers may in fact actually suffer from. You are not a mental health expert, this is pretty far afield of your wheelhouse. You seem to be almost intentionally missing the point. Orthorexia is not and never has been about actual healthy eating habits. It is about the intrusive obsession with healthy eating, to the point that it becomes disruptive to other healthful patterns in your life. It is absolutely a problem if your need to eat perfectly supersedes your relationships and your other life endeavors. If your anxiety is intense during meals, when preparing food, if worry about food dominates your thinking, then you have a problem. It is disappointing to see you give such an unbalanced and uninformed view of this issue, and not consult with actual professionals who might have more insight than you do.

    The questionnaire is problematic, I don’t dispute that. But a bad questionnaire doesn’t negate the existence of a problem. I’ve seen plenty of really poor questionnaires; I absolutely do not experience significant anxiety but according to several poorly-constructed questionnaires I have a moderate anxiety disorder. That doesn’t negate the reality of anxiety disorders, it just means I would be falsely diagnosed with one. An actual mental health professional who understands the limitations of self-reporting, especially in the case of mental health (where your ability to accurately self-report is potentially compromised by the very ailment you seek to treat), would be able to suss out the details of a person’s experience and evaluate whether an actual problem exists. It’s probably true that medication is overused (although I have seen medication for OCD be quite effective, so it isn’t entirely without benefit), but that also doesn’t negate the existence of a problem. Your bias is showing and it is quite disappointing and in fact, since your following is people who are concerned with healthy eating and you very well could attract the very people who might be in need of clinical support, I think it’s actually unethical.

  71. I've witnessed people who have genuine orthorexia, and this video does not describe it. It's not about wanting to eat heathy… It's about avoiding healthy foods in the name of healthy eating.

    Someone who counts calories isn't orthorexic. Someone with a mere food preference isn't orthorexic. Someone who believes that steamed Kale and sweet potatoes are "toxic" and should be avoided at all costs would probably be orthorexic.

    I'm sorry, but I feel like this series on orthorexia is poking fun in a condescending way at a dangerous eating disorder without even knowing what that disorder is actually about.

  73. I've heard there's a strange genetic immunity against orthorexia if you are overweight, have type 2 diabetes and heart disease… sign me up!

  75. Why is there new diseases like these popping up everywhere 😂 orthorexia to me is a type of ocd translated into food, a coping mechanism from anxiety, or rather an effect of a psychological trauma or feeling of a lack of control in life. Most mental illnesses are like that

    This test actually made me laugh because who in their right mind goes “wait, I’m supposed to know what’s going on in a grocery store? I thought they were made to confuse me!”

  82. I agree that the questions are a bit wack, but orthorexia falls under eating disorders and obsessive compulsive disorder. There’s a difference in the desire to eat healthy, and the obsession with eating healthy. People with orthorexia will often obsess over every morsel of food they put in their body throughout the day, and will often not allow themselves a piece of pizza or even a cupcake at a birthday party. This usually leads to binging and purging later on, extreme self-degradation, or even starvation, if the obsession is bad enough. I understand that the condition sounds like someone who “just likes eating healthy”, but it’s much more than that. It’s an obsessive eating disorder that is mostly influenced by social media and dieting fads that takes over your mind. Please be considerate.

  83. Love your work Dr Greger! I wanted to add a consideration…I'm definitely not a fan of these questions but I do think Orthorexia (or tendencies) can be a problem for people with chronic illness particularly things like IBS, inflammatory diseases or autoimmune where even some fruit/veg does actually make you sicker (eg high FODMAP food).

  87. When I tried a vegan diet I "worried often" because I was wondering how my health on many fronts was declining eating the "ideal" diet. Why was my immune system horrible, developing IBS symptoms, developed more cavities, low libido, etc? Figures why many ex-vegans developed orthorexic symptoms. Funny how my immune system and overall health is 10x better eating a flexible diet. Also a recent publication that Dr. Gregor fails to cite in his expose that was the most exhaustive look at Orthorexia research did point to vegans/vegetarians being at a higher risk of developing orthorexia.

  88. These questions were insane. But I still got 39 somehow hahaha I’m not sure if that says anything about me 🤷‍♀️

  89. Comexia:
    Comes from the word comer (to eat).
    Eating any type of food is an eating disorder and you can't do anything right. Just give it up you're trapped.

  90. I love that no one believes this exists. This is real and it’s painful. I have been healthy and unhealthy. For years I have have had a problem with food. It is hard. I hope in the future that some of you will actually take time to learn about his disorder.

  96. I believe that Orthorexia is a real problem, however what a stupid questionnaire!!! They seem to have missed the whole emotional/body image/anxiety driven side to Orthorexia that separates it from just having a healthy relationship with food!

    I did find it interesting though that “always” and “never” were often given fairly similar in ratings. I guess it makes sense when you think about it 🤷‍♀️

  100. I understand your point, but obsessive compulsive disorder when it comes to clean eating and fitness is real. I am what you would consider a clean eater and avid gym enthusiast. My girlfriend is the same but has this condition, she must workout daily, wear her fitbit to know her steps, eat a regimented food schedule, refuses to eat at any foods unless she knows the preparation method. Her life is completely dictated by food, thinking about healthy/clean food and exercise. This condition causes extreme health consequences such as hair loss, swing emotional states, body dysmorphia and physical disease. You are doing a disservice and should be ashamed for making a satire video on this.

I commenti sono chiusi.

Tema Seamless Buone Ricette, sviluppato da Altervista

Apri un sito e guadagna con Altervista - Disclaimer - Segnala abuso - Privacy Policy - Personalizza tracciamento pubblicitario